Skip to main content
Science Catalogs
Health Sciences

Autistic adults show more varied brain responses to films than non-autistic peers

Adults with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and adults without it show closely similar average brain responses while watching films, according to a study in JNeurosci. Within the ASD group, however, individuals departed further from their own group's average, and this was most pronounced in the brain's social system. The work was led by Dorit Kliemann and James Traer at the University of Iowa.

Modelling brain activity during films

The team did not collect new scans. Instead, they reanalysed imaging data gathered earlier at Indiana University and Caltech, in which adults with and without ASD watched a range of films. The selection covered animation, action, romantic comedy and Hitchcock-style thrillers, giving a mix of sensory and social content.

Using these recordings, the researchers trained a computational model to find links between brain activity and three kinds of film content: sounds, visual features and abstract social aspects of each scene. Once trained, the model predicted activity well across several brain systems. This allowed the group to examine responses to many features of dynamic, naturalistic scenes at once, rather than to a single controlled stimulus.

Averages agree, individuals diverge

When the researchers compared the two groups on average, the model predicted activity in each brain system similarly for adults with and without ASD. Traer said the team was surprised by how alike the group averages were.

The picture changed when participants were compared with others in their own group. Adults with ASD deviated more from their group average than comparison participants did. This greater variability appeared in nearly all the brain systems assessed, and it was most marked in the social brain system.

Why this matters for autism research

Much research on ASD, and many ideas about how to support autistic people, rest on contrasts between group averages. The findings suggest that this approach can hide meaningful differences. If averages look alike while individual patterns scatter more widely, a group-level comparison may miss or blur the neural features that matter for any one person.

The authors argue that attention should shift towards the detail of individual brain responses and the reasons they differ. Kliemann suggests that identifying subgroups within ASD could lead to a more precise understanding of the condition and to support tailored to individuals. The work does not yet identify such subgroups.

Limits and next steps

Several points bear on how far the results can be taken. The study used previously collected data from adults, so it says nothing directly about children or about people whose needs differ from those who took part in the original experiments. The findings also concern how brain activity relates to film features, not how that activity translates into everyday behaviour. The source material does not report participant numbers, which would be needed to judge the strength of the variability result.

The team plans to investigate how, where and when this variability links to individual differences in behaviours associated with ASD. That step will test whether the wider spread in brain responses corresponds to differences in social experience or support needs, and whether it can be used to define useful subgroups.

The study is titled "Heterogeneous Encoding Patterns of Dynamic Audiovisual Social Stimuli in Autism Spectrum Disorder" (JNeurosci, 2026; DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0055-26.2026).

Source: People with autism show remarkable variability in brain activity (Medical Xpress, 15 November 2026).

Image: AI-generated illustration.

Working on this topic? Find a journal for your research or join the discussion on Scholars Post.