Ancient DNA shows extinct Caribbean bird was a snipe and maps ocean crossings
DNA recovered from fossils found in a Haitian cave has shown that an extinct bird once classed as a woodcock was in fact a snipe. Placing it in a dated family tree of nearly all living woodcocks and snipes revealed two long westward ocean crossings that the birds' conventional north-south migration routes would not predict. The study, led by Min Zhao and colleagues at the Florida Museum of Natural History, appears in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
A misidentified fossil
The bones were excavated from a cave on Hispaniola in 1984 and were assigned to a woodcock in 2015. Woodcocks and snipes are each other's closest relatives, having split from a common ancestor roughly 25 million years ago, and they can look very alike. The fossil birds also had short wings and large legs, a pairing often seen in island species, which may have added to the confusion. Sequencing ancient DNA from the specimens placed them firmly among the snipes.
Building a dated family tree
The team then widened the question. Collaborators took small tissue samples from museum collections across the United States, covering all but one of the 29 living woodcock and snipe species. Jessica Oswald extracted and sequenced the DNA, with help from Brian Stucky for the fossil material. She also added the South Island snipe, which died out in 1964 after black rats reached the South and Stewart islands of New Zealand.
The researchers combined the genetic data with the ages of shorebird fossils to produce a time-calibrated phylogeny, a species-level tree with dates attached.
Unexpected journeys across oceans
The tree points to a tangled geographical history. About 20 million years ago, woodcocks spread from Eurasia, where the group arose, into North America. Routes via the Russia-Alaska region, or via Iceland and Greenland, make that move easy to imagine. At about the same time, Eurasian snipes reached South America and diversified there. The extinct Caribbean snipe belongs to this South American radiation.
The Eurasian snipes' passage to South America required flying west across an entire ocean. About seven million years later, South American snipes appear to have made a still longer journey, to islands in the south-west Pacific, where they diversified again.
That second result was unexpected. The austral snipes of New Zealand and nearby islands, known in Māori as tutukiwi, differ enough in appearance from other snipes that they are placed in their own genus, Coenocorypha. The genetic data nonetheless nest them within a lineage made up mostly of South American snipes. Resolving this would require either merging Coenocorypha into Gallinago or creating two new genera for the South American relatives. The authors did not propose any taxonomic changes.
Island birds and missing links
Woodcocks and snipes are unusual among long-distance migrant shorebirds because several lineages abandoned migration and settled on islands. Six of the eight living woodcock species are island endemics, and the group has radiated across the Caribbean, Japan, Indonesia, the western Pacific and the New Zealand region. David Steadman, emeritus curator of ornithology at the museum, notes that no other migratory shorebirds have established resident island populations in this way.
The authors are unsure whether the trans-Pacific jump really happened as a single leap. One hypothesis, put forward by Oswald, is that related snipes once lived on many Pacific islands and were later lost, leaving a gap in the record. This would parallel earlier work from the same group on Caribbean cave rails, whose closest relatives turned out to live in New Zealand, Africa and the South Pacific rather than the Americas.
Human arrival is the likely cause of such losses. Hunting and introduced predators such as rats and cats have removed many island birds. The Caribbean snipe vanished at some point after the 17th century, and six other species in Coenocorypha appear to have met a similar end.
Why it matters
The work shows how ancient DNA from fossils and museum specimens can correct identifications and reshape biogeographic reasoning, especially where extinction has erased intermediate populations. Finding further fossils on Pacific islands, and sequencing them where preservation allows, would be the obvious way to test whether lost snipe species once bridged the gap to New Zealand.
Source: The avian champions of long-distance migration keep surprising scientists (Phys.org, 22 November 2026).
Image: AI-generated illustration.
Working on this topic? Find a journal for your research or join the discussion on Scholars Post.


